Welcome to the Realm

Where Readers & Writers Connect

Review: The Greatest Gift (It’s a Wonderful Life) by Philip Van Doren Stern

This continues our series this month on our readers’ favorite books to movies (although this one was technically not a book).

Christmas in July! (My Thoughts on It’s a Wonderful Life)

by Sheila Hollinghead

Every Christmas, my family becomes slightly annoyed with me. At least, they pretend to be annoyed. Why? Simply because I insist we watch one of the most beloved Christmas movies of all time–It’s a Wonderful Life.

It’s a Wonderful Life began as a 4,000-word short story entitled “The Greatest Gift.” Written in 1939 by editor and historian Philip Van Doren Stern, the story was rejected numerous times by publishers. Four years later, Stern decided to take matters into his own hands. He printed 200 copies of this tale of a man in despair who finds redemption and sent the story to friends and family as Christmas cards.

One of these “cards” came to the attention of a producer at RKO Pictures. RKO purchased the motion picture rights for $10,000 and the rest is history–repeated year after year in my home.

What is the appeal of this timeless tale? We identify with George. Most people have relinquished dreams and teetered at times on the edge of bitterness. George feels trapped, just as we often do, and wonders if his life has meaning. He ponders jumping into the icy cold river.

Before he can, he tells a strange man he wishes he had never been born. And the man grants his wish. When George explores this alternative reality of life without himself, he discovers he has made a difference in the world. He discovers this is the place he is meant to be. This is the life he was meant to live.

In the movie version, he actually succeeds in thwarting the schemes of Mr. Potter without fully realizing it until his guardian angel reveals it to him. This is the type of story we love–the story of a David and Goliath. George, an average man, stands against the most powerful man in Bedford Falls. Not only stands against him but wins.

George discovers that his life is a wonderful life and has been all along–even when he was in the depths of despair. The story and the movie adaptation answers the age-old question: What is our purpose here on earth?

We all have moments in the valley, moments when we do not see our purpose in life, when our hopes and dreams have been dashed, when we are trapped in circumstances beyond our control. Often, these moments are deceptive.

We can only see the reality when viewed from a different viewpoint, a viewpoint among the stars in the heavens. Then, we truly know, It’s a Wonderful Life

even when our family grumbles about our movie choices!

And here’s the “phone” scene for your viewing pleasure:

# # #

Sheila Hollinghead is the author of  Thundersnow (In the Shadow of the Cedar) and Eternal Springs: 366 Daily Inspirations. She lives on a south Alabama farm with her husband of thirty-one years.


9 comments on “Review: The Greatest Gift (It’s a Wonderful Life) by Philip Van Doren Stern

  1. pastorgeorgemcvey
    July 17, 2012

    Had never heard of the short story but I love this movie as well. Make my family suffer through it as well

    • sheilahollinghead
      July 18, 2012

      Yes, George, it’s a shame what our families have to put up with! 🙂

      • pastorgeorgemcvey
        July 18, 2012

        yep between that movie and A christmas story my family runs away screaming

  2. Carole Brown
    July 17, 2012

    Sheila great post. Really enjoyed it.

    • sheilahollinghead
      July 18, 2012

      Thanks, Carole!

  3. Traci B
    July 17, 2012

    Excellent review, Sheila. I never heard of the story either, but the tale of its transformation into the iconic Christmas movie is inspiring. 🙂

    • sheilahollinghead
      July 18, 2012

      It gives us hope, doesn’t it? That a story rejected can become one of the top movies of all times!

      • Traci B
        July 19, 2012

        Yes it does, Sheila. Thanks for sharing the back story with us.

  4. Pingback: The Top Five Books to Movies from Readers’ Realm Poll « Welcome to the Realm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s


This entry was posted on July 17, 2012 by in Book Reviews and tagged , .

Our Weekly Schedule

Mondays - Author Interviews
Wednesdays - Book Reviews
Fridays - Flash Fiction and Short Stories

Follow Readers Realm by Email!

%d bloggers like this: